Nearly 1,200 readers of TheHorse.com responded to a poll asking, “What concerns do you have about short- and long-term pain management in horses?”






results of poll on helping horses shed

Results were as follows (multiple selections were allowed): 

  • Side effects, such as ulcers: 84.17%  (989)
  • Effectiveness (or lack thereof): 63.66%  (748)
  • Positive drug tests: 8.60%  (101)
  • Other: 6.81%  (80)

Readers shared their questions about pain management in the comments below.

Results of weekly polls from TheHorse.com are published in The Horse Health E-Newsletter. Published every week, this e-newsletter offers news on diseases, veterinary research, health events, and in-depth articles on common equine health conditions and what you can do to recognize, avoid, or treat them. Sign up for our e-newsletters using the form above or on our e-newsletter page.  

Look for a new poll on TheHorse.com every week!




  • We had a horse that might have needed it but then we had to just give him back due to them money 🙁
  • Masking the symptoms and not addressing the cause.
  • Does my horse really need it? How will it help my horse top heal?
  • Is Leg pain the worst?
  • With poor management of pain in humans, can we be sure our horses are the best pain relief available?
  • Masking pain for strenuous athletic endeavors is a dangerous thing to do.
  • Should I give my paint horse Bute for shoe boil?
  • What’s best besides Bute? Also give a natural painkiller for arthritis every other day.
  • Cure for colic
  • I’m looking for the best pain relief with the least side effects.
  • Why are alternative natural analgesics more commonly used?
  • Administration of pain meds
  • Alternatives to products that may cause ulcers
  • Is there a better way to regulate supplements?
  • Knock on wood…I’ve been very fortunate to not to use it often at all; therefore, I have none.
  • My friend’s horse has arthritis and is permanently on Bute. She still rides her.is that ok?
  • Safe use in pregnant mares and use in foals with pain management issues
  • I don’t want a bunch of drug-addict horses
  • Arthritis
  • Is there a drug to help with possible nerve damage & inflammation for horses?
  • Safe procedures while awaiting vet
  • Drug reactions are a concern, too
  • Is there anything that can be used during AQHA competition that won’t ruin the horse’s health?
  • Seems crazy to dull pain in one area only to create it in the stomach!
  • Other-Am I doing what is best for the horse?
  • None, horses don’t feel pain, unless I give it to them
  • Over long-term pain management, how do you know it is still effective or needed?
  • Increasing injury by masking pain, continuing the causative activity. Treating symptom, not cause.
  • – If they can’t feel the pain they can get WORSE injuries…care is needed with pain meds
  • Side effect, such as skin lesion, thrombophebitis
  • Are pain meds being used to mask performance and training issues that should be addressed first?
  • Damages to the horse due to lack of sensing…
  • Why can’t this medicine be buffered like it is for humans?
  • Quality of life.
  • What about the concern when pain management is not what’s best for the horse?
  • Can natural remedies work sufficiently without the side effects?
  • That Bute given regularly is very hard on the stomach.
  • My biggest concern tends to be the reasons that an animal needs long-term pain management.
  • Does managing pain increase the likeliness of reinjury or exacerbating the existing injury?
  • Managing pain but masking the real problem
  • Should it be administered an hour before performance or after?
  • Preventing ulcers in miniature horses on Bute
  • WHAT’S ENOUGH? EASE PAIN, BUT NOT ENCOURAGE OVEREXERTION OF STRAINED
  • MUSCLES.
  • When will affordable COX-2 inhibitors be available in the U.S?
  • Always keep Bute and banamine in tack room.
  • My boy got “hooked” on ACE on 30 days of stall rest.
  • Stiffness before & after exercise treatment
  • Cost
  • In too many cases, pain management treats the SYMPTOM, not the cause.
  • The damage to the digestive system with prolonged use.
  • What do people use besides Bute for pain mgmt not joint related. I use devils claw.
  • I don’t know what is healthy for long-term management
  • Allows continued movement w/pain meds allows further damage-get vet diagnosis before give pain meds
  • Bute kills. That’s why it was taken off the market for humans.
  • For chronic issues, there doesn’t seem to be a treatment that provides truly effective relief
  • It doesn’t seem like there are really good, effective long-term pain relief solutions yet!
  • How to know what pain medications to use for different types of pain such as arthritis vs. other
  • I don’t use for long, I want the horse to know it has pain so as not to reinjure.
  • We need a positive list (by days) and side effects warning in short
  • I question if pain is in relation to an injury, if masking the pain would result in further injury?
  • What’s the best way to counteract adverse effects of log term Bute for arthritis?
  • They need to reformulate Bute to include buffering against ulcers
  • Quality of life
  • Worried about pain management in pregnant mares.
  • Osselets treatment
  • Possibility of damaging side effects from the long-term use of antinflamitory drugs…kidney problems
  • What pain relief is safe for pregnant mares?
  • We have NO concerns in this, as we own Sumerel Therapy,which naturally and effectively relieves pain
  • What product is the best for simple, long-term usage?
  • liver damage
  • availability, cost of dosages,
  • bute long term too common
  • I worry that the pain mgmt drugs still in their system when they’re processed for food.
  • With uveitis one is stuck giving pain meds!
  • Pain is a healing response, always worried about taking too much pain away , poss causingmore damag
  • why dont horse owners use natural herbal pain killers instead of using bute
  • Need long-term pain control with minimal side-effects.
  • Reducing pain is important but masking it does little to determine causes and preventing recurrence.
  • When pain is relieved, horse may move around more causing more damage.
  • masking real problems, exacerbating concerns.
  • Other: the concern that many horses are horrible patients and can be dangerous to treat.
  • We are in need of more choices for affordable equine pain management
  • pain support for the geriatric horse is a large concern, especially reproductive mares that
  • allergies
  • Overall effect on horse and expense.
  • are we just treating symptoms, what’s really going on to cause the pain?
  • 1. IR horse medications restrictions 2. Effectiveness 3. Side Effects
  • How do you know how if you can stop using drugs
  • Layperson’s recognizing signs of pain in particularly stoic horses
  • On pain meds my mare ran in the field and re-injured her tendon–because she didn’t feel the injury?
  • I am using Duralactin for arthritis on one of my horses. Does it really work to alleiviate the pain
  • safety of 1 gram of bute a day for maintenance
  • Isn’t there an alternative to bute?
  • WHAT IS A SAFE DAILY DOSAGE OF BUTE FOR A LA,E HORSE THAT BECOMES SOUND ON A
  • 5MG DOSE?
  • What pain relievers can be given to a horse that can’t have bute or Banamine due to colonic ulcers?
  • masking symptoms
  • How often and how much Butte can you safely give a 1200 pound horse?
  • We use non-drug methods like ice and massage when possible.
  • My horse goes to physical therapy for a torn ligament, should I treat him afterwards?
  • Having a horse in a condition where he needs pain management.
  • drug tolerance and bute ruining the stomach lining
  • what are the best natural pain meds for horses that are in very light work/semi retired?
  • How do you know if pain meds are effective
  • aggravating damage by removing theprotective nature of pain and failing to treat the root cause
  • Ulcers and the pain after treatment
  • how it affects the horses over all physiological state.
  • Kidney and Liver damage.
  • Masking further symtoms or horse injuring itself further due to pain relief
  • Addicted horses can be extremely aggressive. Ouch!
  • Long-term negative impact on health with older products
  • Short term, is it effective (enough) and long term damage are concerns….
  • Animals are not human, treating long term pain without a return to usefullness is wrong.
  • What works the best is the most important question to me
  • I worry that the pain mgmt drugs still in their system when they’re processed for food.
  • I dose probiotics generously to mitigate
  • Adequan and Legend are really miracle drugs
  • That the horse maintains a good quality of life!
  • back pain medication
  • how can you tell its really benifiting your horse?
  • how do we know what works?

TheHorse.com is home to thousands of free articles about horse health care. In order to access some of our exclusive free content, you must be signed into TheHorse.com.

Start your free account today!

Already have an account?
and continue reading.