6 Reasons Your Horse Might Be Suddenly Spooky

Your horse used to be unflappable, whether you were riding through open fields or past tarp-covered rooftops and flags blowing in the wind. But now he’s spooking at familiar objects he once passed without a second glance.
When a normally confident horse suddenly starts spooking, owners shouldn’t ignore the behavior or assume they can resolve it through retraining without first investigating the cause. Here are six possible explanations.
1. Equine Vision Problems
Cataracts, retinal disease, uveitis, and keratitis can all change how horses perceive familiar objects, potentially making them scary, says Richard McMullen, Dr. med. vet., Dipl. ACVO, ECVO, an equine ophthalmologist at the University of Zurich, in Switzerland.
When horses spook due to poor vision, they might shy from obstacles, which become more difficult to recognize, or resist moving between light and dark areas, he says. Perhaps counterintuitively, though, horses tend to spook less when they’ve lost sight in the eye completely.
Veterinarians can check a horse’s vision relatively easily, McMullen says, making it a good starting point in working up sudden spookiness.
2. Equine Neurologic Diseases
Problems affecting the brain or spinal cord can lead to spookiness in horses, says Amy Johnson, DVM, Dipl. ACVIM (LAIM and neurology), assistant professor at the University of Pennsylvania’s New Bolton Center, in Kennett Square.
That includes both infectious diseases such as equine protozoal myeloencephalitis (EPM) and noninfectious ones, including cervical vertebral stenotic myelopathy (CVSM, or wobbler disease) and equine degenerative myeloencephalopathy (EDM). Veterinarians might also consider West Nile virus (WNV), Lyme neuroborreliosis (the rare neurologic form of Lyme disease), and neurologic equine herpesvirus-1 (EHV-1).
Sudden spooking might serve as an early red flag for such neurologic problems. In her recent research Johnson found owners whose horses were eventually diagnosed with EDM or equine neuroaxonal dystrophy (eNAD) initially sought veterinary evaluations for unpredictable spooking or other behavioral issues, before noticing more classic neurologic signs such as weakness or ataxia (incoordination).
Spooking related to neurologic problems can sometimes be associated with stumbling, an uneven stride, difficulty changing leads, or unexpected falls, Johnson says.
3. Pain or Discomfort
Horses in pain are often prone to spooking, says Ben Sykes, BSc, BVMS, MS, Dipl. ACVIM, MBA, of BW Sykes Consultancy, in New South Wales, Australia. That’s because sharp or unexpected pain can trigger the fight-or-flight response. What appears to be an inexplicable spook might have a very concrete cause: Something hurts.
“We see spooking as an undesirable behavior, but from their perspective it’s a perfectly logical and appropriate behavioral response embedded in their evolution,” he says. “They don’t know why it hurts; they just know it hurts.”
Conditions such as impinging dorsal spinous processes (kissing spines) can contribute to spooking, for example. So can equine gastric ulcer syndrome (EGUS), Sykes says. Researchers have associated both conditions with unwanted behavior.
Still, these aren’t the only types of pain horses can have, and they might not be the reason for the spooking even if horses have them, Sykes says. Veterinarians should also investigate other potential sources of pain, including lameness, back pain (even soreness caused by poor saddle fit), and dental or oral disease. Owners should also have their riding equipment evaluated for fit, says Manuela McLean, an instructor at Equitation Science International, in Tuerong, Victoria.
4. Nutrition Problems
Researchers have shown high-starch diets might make equids more reactive, less settled, and more responsive to novel or startling stimuli in general than those fed higher-fiber or higher-fat diets.
So, could that make them spook? Probably, McLean says. “It’s like a kid on red cordial,” she explains, referring to the Australian equivalent of Kool-Aid. “They can get hyperactive.”
In addition, veterinarians know high-starch diets, especially on an empty stomach, favor equine squamous gastric disease (ESGD), a form of EGUS that could “make horses flinch or be more reactive to the leg,” says Shannon Pratt-Phillips, MS, PhD, professor of equine nutrition and director of Distance Education Animal Science Programs at North Carolina State University, in Raleigh.
Horse owners frequently cite magnesium deficiency as a cause for spookiness, but true magnesium deficiency in horses is rare, she says. And while low magnesium might cause nervousness and neuromuscular signs, researchers so far have found little evidence that magnesium supplements make horses calmer.
In general, supplements might seem like a way to fix spooking, but nutrition probably isn’t the reason if the diet has been stable. “If the spooking is truly sudden—and nothing else has changed—then that isn’t where I would think to look,” Pratt-Phillips says.
5. Trigger-Stacking in Horses
Frustration or repeated negative experiences, even seemingly minor ones such as hearing other horses whinny or experiencing mild physical discomfort, can make horses increasingly sensitive to their surroundings, lowering their threshold for stress.
Such trigger stacking can lead to horses essentially being on edge, making them more reactive to even slight sources of stress or surprise, says Gemma Pearson, BVMS, PhD, a lecturer at the University of Edinburgh, in Scotland. “It’s like the straw that breaks the camel’s back. They overreact, much the way we do when we’re just having a really bad day.”
Chronic stress from issues such as restricted movement or limited social contact compromises horses’ welfare and might also make them more sensitive to additional stressors, McLean says. Plus, individual housing and lack of social contact can cause horses to feel less secure and more vigilant about their surroundings.
Training styles can create underlying tension as well, McLean adds. Trainers and riders might confuse or frustrate horses by giving unclear or conflicting aids, for example, or delivering reinforcement at the wrong time.
“If vision problems are not involved, and it is not a genuine startle response to a sudden stimulus, it could just be generalized sensitization after one or more negative experiences, or because of suboptimal management,” says Marc Pierard, PhD, senior lecturer in animal and veterinary sciences at the University of Lancashire, in the U.K.
6. Because Spooking Becomes a Learned Response
Horses might find spooking to be the only solution to an unsolvable problem, especially during a training session, McLean says. For example, a rider attempting lateral work might apply several aids in rapid succession, prompting a horse to shy as a flight response if he hasn’t learned what each aid means or can’t distinguish between them. The rider might then lose her balance or otherwise stop the aids and unintentionally reinforce the reaction. The change might appear sudden but in reality the behavior has been reinforced over time.
“If this spooking behavior results in something the horse finds rewarding—gets rid of a nagging rider, gives him some time to run around freely—it can become a learned behavior,” Pierard explains.
In essence, they learn they can benefit from the spook, so they keep doing it, says Andy Booth, a science-based Australian horse trainer based in Southern France. Importantly, that doesn’t make the horse naughty or deceitful, he adds.
Take-Home Message
Sudden spooking can be challenging for owners and riders to decipher. But do not dismiss the response as the horse being badly behaved, our sources say. The behavior can stem from significant physical health problems, environmental stress, or training-related difficulties that warrant investigation. “Spooking might be their way of communication,” says Sykes. “We just need to make sure we listen.”

Related Articles
Stay on top of the most recent Horse Health news with










