Selenium and Cribbing: Is There a Relationship?

Researchers have learned that crib-biting (or cribbing) in horses might be related to a lack of trace element selenium in their diets.

The research team, led by Arash Omidi, DVM, PhD, of Shiraz University, in Iran, and including Matthew Parker, BSc, MSc, PhD, of the University of Portsmouth, in the U.K., say their findings suggest crib-biting shares similar characteristics with some human neurologic or psychiatric conditions such as schizophrenia and autism.

The study is the first to test the role of trace elements in crib-biting, a repetitive and compulsive behavior some horses develop where they bite an object and grunt.

“Selenium deficiency has been linked to some human psychiatric conditions and even to bad moods, but until now, there has been no research on the effect of trace elements in crib-biting horses,” said Parker, of the university’s School of Pharmacy and Biomedical Sciences. “Crib-biting is a compulsive disorder that can be distressing for owners, can cause damage to teeth and has been linked to colic. Owners and vets worldwide have tried numerous ways of fixing it without success.

“It’s too soon to know for certain if selenium in the diet will help or even cure the condition, but the crib-biting horses we tested were deficient in selenium,” he added.

He urged caution over selenium dosages, though, warning too much would be toxic to horses. The recommended daily amount of dietary selenium is 0.1 mg/kg of daily diet, but more than 2 mg/kg is toxic.

For horses, selenium is found naturally in hay, pasture, and grain. It is also commonly added to commercial horse food, underlining the importance of owners checking their horse’s existing dosage from commercial foods and the foraging environment before adding more.

“People should be very careful giving selenium supplements,” Parker stressed. “Some soil, particularly in parts of the USA, have selenium-rich soil and adding a selenium supplement can be dangerous.

“Selenium is an important antioxidant that helps the body to protect itself from the damage caused by free-radicals, or oxidative stress,” he continued. “Our results suggest it could be that a lack of selenium in the diet increases the oxidative damage on neurological systems, causing or exacerbating the problem.”

Low levels of selenium have previously been recorded in humans with schizophrenia, a condition which, the researchers say, is more common in areas where the soil contains very low levels of selenium. For humans, selenium can be sourced from Brazil nuts, eggs, chicken, and a range of other foods.

The researchers tested the blood of crib-biting and non-crib-biting horses for nine trace elements—selenium, magnesium, zinc, sodium, potassium, copper, calcium, phosphorus, and manganese—during crib-biting and afterwards. All mammals, including horses and humans, need tiny amounts of these trace elements to function well and all can be sourced from food, if the diet is good.

They also tested for enzymes, glucose, endorphins, and some hormones, including cortisol, the so-called stress hormone.

Crib-biting has been recorded in a small proportion of the horse population for centuries but no conclusive reason for the behavior has yet been found. It has been blamed on a host of different things including boredom, a side effect of ulcers, or too much sugar in the diet. Some believe the behavior gives horses an endorphin rush, making a horse want to keep doing it. It is almost always seen in horses who are stabled and is said to cause expensive damage to stables and a great deal of worry for owners.

In the next phase of their research, Parker and his team will be examining the effects on crib-biting of dietary supplements, in particular, diets high in selenium and other antioxidants.

The study, “Potential roles of Selenium and Zinc in the pathophysiology of crib-biting behavior in horses,” was published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior: Clinical Applications and Research.